yup, this is an ad!
Napalm Riot Forums > Site Suggestions > Delete comments

Delete comments

    Avatar
    Rank
    Private First Class
    Creed
    Role-Playing
    Joined
    01.14.08

ɤVincent

Rolls Twenties

It would be nice to be able to delete comments that you posted or that are on your profile. This would help if someone was spamming you, sending you negative comments, or someone said something that really doesn't need to be on the internet.

Or if your profile happens to be like mine and is all stretched out and jacked up because you have a comment the size of a book page...
---
Hard rain don't last
06.14.08 2:58 pm
    • Avatar
      Rank
      General of the Riot
      Creed
      Strategy
      Uber Subscriber Joined
      11.07.07

    ӝNirach (#22021)

    Worrying is about as effective as chewing gum to solve algebra

    I see where you're coming from, I really do.

    However, if there was the chance that comments could be deleted, then there's always a chance that something could be posted maliciously, and then deleted before anything was to come of it in terms of staff seeing it, that kind of thing.

    It's in the same vein as being able to edit comments on pages/screenshots/etc.

    For example. Say someone posted a comment on a blog of yours that was really, really offensive and was not at all provoked. You report it, but before anyone has a chance to look at it the poster deletes it, there'd be nothing feasible that could be done, as it would be your word against theirs - Which rarely pans out well in terms of getting the whole thing resolved.

    So, while I see exactly what you mean, and I do understand the benefits of such a system, it is also incredibly open to abuse, so much so that it wouldn't be sensible to offer the option.
    ---
    Keep your eyes peeled for the average gamers.
    Nothing's broken, it's just functioning differently.
    06.14.08 3:20 pm
      • Avatar
        Rank
        Private First Class
        Creed
        Role-Playing
        Joined
        01.14.08

      ɤVincent (#22024)

      Rolls Twenties

      Honestly I didn't think of that... But thankyou for considering it...

      My profile is kinda irritating though, I have seen another members just like mine to
      ---
      Hard rain don't last
      06.14.08 3:22 pm
        • Avatar
          Rank
          General of the Riot
          Creed
          Strategy
          Uber Subscriber Joined
          11.07.07

        ӝNirach (#22050)

        Worrying is about as effective as chewing gum to solve algebra

        I thought being able to delete comments was a good idea until it was put to me in that light, too, so you're not alone!

        I do understand what you mean, though, and I would like to see some comment management system myself - But it's not something that we can solve just yet, so maybe in the future when we have more time to come up with brainwaves on the subject we can get something done.
        ---
        Keep your eyes peeled for the average gamers.
        Nothing's broken, it's just functioning differently.
        06.14.08 9:51 pm
      • Avatar
        Rank
        Sergeant
        Creed
        Action
        Joined
        03.17.08

      ʊaapis (#24877)

      Isn't my real name.

      That's usually what they say on sites that don't allow comment deletion, and I completely agree. The way I see it, if you aren't comfortable with what you're posting online you probably shouldn't be doing it. :p
      ---
      Ryan Priebe
      UI & Graphic Designer
      Napalm Riot Inc.
      09.18.08 2:30 am
    • Avatar
      Rank
      Corporal
      Creed
      Action
      Uber Subscriber Joined
      11.07.07

    ʊchalkley3 (#22023)

    I go where I please, and I please where I go

    I suppose, but it also opens the system to the same abuse myspace etc. suffer. Say something nasty, delete the comment, and you still look good. I'm all for eternal shame, and I'm sure if you were having an issue with a user, an admin would sort it out. I suppose long comments are an issue, they still haven't figured out a good solution to insane levels of replys breaking the layout.
    06.14.08 3:21 pm
      • Avatar
        Rank
        Private First Class
        Creed
        Role-Playing
        Joined
        01.14.08

      ɤVincent (#22025)

      Rolls Twenties

      That is my main irritation... Hopefully they will be able to fix the layout issues...

      As for the abuse, I'm not sure what to do about it though...
      ---
      Hard rain don't last
      06.14.08 3:24 pm
        • Avatar
          Rank
          Corporal
          Creed
          Action
          Uber Subscriber Joined
          11.07.07

        ʊchalkley3 (#22028)

        I go where I please, and I please where I go

        Well, if it's something obvious like spam or hate, then a note to ӝnirach or ӝspot should iron things out quickly, but if it's just a personal feud, then the onus is on you to sort it out. It's the same with any community.
        06.14.08 3:29 pm
    • Avatar
      Rank
      Private First Class
      Creed
      Strategy
      Joined
      12.17.07

    ɤSilentkey (#22034)

    Wipes Groups For Fun

    i think a delete would be great
    06.14.08 3:37 pm
      • Avatar
        Rank
        Private First Class
        Creed
        Role-Playing
        Joined
        01.14.08

      ɤVincent (#22037)

      Rolls Twenties

      I would like to have one... But i understand Nirache's point
      ---
      Hard rain don't last
      06.14.08 3:48 pm
        • Avatar
          Rank
          Private First Class
          Creed
          Strategy
          Joined
          12.17.07

        ɤSilentkey (#22040)

        Wipes Groups For Fun

        i do too......idk how do other forums do it?
        06.14.08 3:57 pm
    • Avatar
      Rank
      Corporal
      Creed
      MMO
      Joined
      10.17.07

    ¤Sangue (#22161)

    Is laying mines for the good of all.

    I would suggest something more along the lines of hiding offensive comments from the public/yourself, that way the staff could still see the comments and be able to take action as needed.
    ---
    Napalm Riot's News Babe.
    06.16.08 6:12 am
      • Avatar
        Rank
        Private First Class
        Creed
        Role-Playing
        Joined
        01.14.08

      ɤVincent (#22250)

      Rolls Twenties

      That a good idea... And then just fix profile formatting bug and it would be better all around
      ---
      Hard rain don't last
      06.17.08 1:31 am
    • Avatar
      Rank
      Corporal
      Creed
      Simulation
      Joined
      05.23.08

    ʊHAL (#24742)

    The Cake Is A Lie

    Well instead of the deleting comments system, or a hide comments system, I'd be most fond of an "amend comments" system, that would allow you to just add an extra line or two to the end of a comment that you made, that way you could point out that you made a spelling mistake, without having to make another comment which can then get very confusing.

    In addition, I think that the hiding of comments should probably be left to staff-only, since comment-hiding systems are also ripe for abuse. However a "report comment" button would be great on all of them, for everyone to use. ;)
    ---
    -HAL
    09.11.08 11:53 pm
      • Avatar
        Rank
        Corporal
        Creed
        Simulation
        Joined
        05.23.08

      ʊHAL (#24743)

      The Cake Is A Lie

      Ooops... necro'd.

      My bad.
      ---
      -HAL
      09.11.08 11:57 pm
    • Avatar
      Rank
      General of the Riot
      Creed
      MMO
      Joined
      02.21.06

    ӝspot (#25351)

    Chief Instigator

    I have been giving this a lot of thought and have some ideas for improving the system and giving you at least some control over what is displayed or not on your page, etc.

    Nothing that will be happening immediately, but we are working on it.

    Stay tuned!
    ---
    I, Gamer!
    10.21.08 5:18 pm